• Latest
  • Trending

New Whiskers Phenomena?

Würth Elektronik Launches New Line of Toggle Switches

Würth Elektronik Launches New Line of Toggle Switches

Microwave Multi Line Connectors Mounting and Handling Precautions

Microwave Multi Line Connectors Mounting and Handling Precautions

PCNS Passive Components Symposium 11-14th September 2023
Flex Suppressor Explained and its Applications

Flex Suppressor Explained and its Applications

Exploring the Benefits of High-Performance MLCC Capacitors for Aerospace and Defense

Exploring the Benefits of High-Performance MLCC Capacitors for Aerospace and Defense

Murata Establishes Joint Venture Company to Produce MLCC Raw Materials

Murata Establishes Joint Venture Company to Produce MLCC Raw Materials

Samtec New Interconnects Enhances Power and Signal Integrity

Samtec New Interconnects Enhances Power and Signal Integrity

Examining the Influence of ESR and Ripple Current on Selecting the Suitable Capacitor

Examining the Influence of ESR and Ripple Current on Selecting the Suitable Capacitor

PCB Via Design Selection; Plugging-Filling-Tenting

PCB Via Design Selection; Plugging-Filling-Tenting

SABIC Validates its 150°C Film Foil to Enable Adoption of Film Capacitors in SIC Power Modules

SABIC Validates its 150°C Film Foil to Enable Adoption of Film Capacitors in SIC Power Modules

Outlook of Passive Electronic Components Market for Oil & Gas Electronics in 2023

Outlook of Passive Electronic Components Market for Oil and Gas Electronics in 2023

  • Home
  • ABC of CLR
    • All
    • ABC of Capacitors
    • ABC of Inductors
    • ABC of Resistors
    • Mounting Guidelines

    RF Inductors and Filters

    Power transformers

    Telecom transformers

    LAN transformers

    Transformer Calculation and Applications

    Power Inductors 2 (cont.)

    Power inductors

    Current compensated chokes

    Coil with ferrite

    Trending Tags

      • ABC of Capacitors
      • ABC of Inductors
      • ABC of Resistors
      • Mounting Guidelines
    • e-Symposium
    • EPCI Membership
    • About
    No Result
    View All Result
    European Passive Components Institute
    • Home
    • ABC of CLR
      • All
      • ABC of Capacitors
      • ABC of Inductors
      • ABC of Resistors
      • Mounting Guidelines

      RF Inductors and Filters

      Power transformers

      Telecom transformers

      LAN transformers

      Transformer Calculation and Applications

      Power Inductors 2 (cont.)

      Power inductors

      Current compensated chokes

      Coil with ferrite

      Trending Tags

        • ABC of Capacitors
        • ABC of Inductors
        • ABC of Resistors
        • Mounting Guidelines
      • e-Symposium
      • EPCI Membership
      • About
      No Result
      View All Result
      European Passive Components Institute
      No Result
      View All Result
      Home e-Symposium

      New Whiskers Phenomena?

      August 26, 2022
      Reading Time: 7 mins read
      31 1
      A A

      by Jean Pascal Michelet and Jean Edmond Le Calvé
      VALEO Créteil, France

      submitted to the 2nd PCNS 10-13th September 2019, Bucharest, Romania as paper 4.4.

      Introduction

      Some PCBAs were submitted to a whisker test +85°C 85% RH for 200h duration and additional 2h from +85°C/85% RH-T° +25°C/50% RH 5 Cycles. The functional test pass and boards were sent to an external lab for visual inspection. Inspection failed because of Tin whiskers detected on MLCCs terminations.

      As reminder a whisker is a spontaneous columnar or cylindrical filament, usually of monocrystalline metal, emanating from the surface of a finish. In automotive electronic the most common are Tin Whiskers growing on Tin platted Copper surfaces. Our suppliers delivering components with Tin or Tin alloy finishes, if no whiskers mitigation method is used or efficiency demonstrated, should perform whisker tests according to JESD-201 standard / 22A121 method [1] [2].

      As many Multi-Layer-Ceramic-Capacitors (MLCCs) got whiskers, we returned to the Bill of Material (BOM) and traceability to find out exactly the part numbers. We went back to their qualifying and the results were good. We also checked the Process Change Notification (PCN) history to see if the suppliers submitted any PCN relative to the termination scheme and we did not find any on this topic. Moreover, all the impacted MLCCs got a Nickel barrier between Copper electrode and Nickel platting supposed to avoid or limit the Tin whiskers growth.

      Observations

      Fig 1: Observations of the whiskers

      Observations of the whiskers: Lengths are measured up to 225μm. Whiskers have tubular shapes. They are located on the sides only, never on the top (not possible to observe the bottom). Whiskers are located between the Tin platted termination and the flux rise.

      The shape of these whiskers is not conventional and is not described neither by the NASA [3] nor by JEDEC [2]. Some hollow whiskers were reported [4], [5], We did not find any document on Tubular whiskers growth on Electronic components. For us it is the first observation of such structure.

      Fig2: EDX analysis evidenced Tin, Bromide, Barium and Oxygen. Barium is coming for the BaTiO3 ceramic from X7R
      MLCC. Bromide origin is unknown
      Fig3: The shape of “standard” Whiskers was observed on another component terminal and compared with those found
      on the MLCCs
      Fig4: The whiskers in question are hollow like micro-tubes. They are transparent and very brittle
      Fig5: The micro-tubes are like bamboo canes with a succession of segments. Some have their end slit on the side

      Root Cause Analysis

      A cross section was done in the horizontal plane of a MLCC at the maximum flux rise where the Whiskers grow.

      Fig6: The extremity of the termination evidenced Tin over Nickel and Copper. Tin is partially oxidized (grey color) like
      whiskers. In the section plan the tubular shape is evidenced. Whiskers growth is on the ceramic nearby or in contact
      with the Tin edge of Tin layer
      Fig7: The edge of the Tin layer is oxidized by Bromide. The crack between the ceramic and the termination is a minor
      polishing artefact. Bromide origin was identified as coming from the Solder Flux

      Risk Analysis

      The major risk of metallic whisker is to reduce the insulation distance or worst to make a short circuit. In our case the whiskers is made of Tin, Oxygen and Bromide. The visual observation evidenced transparent tubular structure, so it is not a pure metal, but a compound of Tin oxide + Bromide.

      Tin oxide is classified as wide band gap (3.6 eV) N-type semiconductor. Considering the risk to have a conductive path, we make electrical verification. We did several attempts to contact the Whiskers by probing but it failed because of whiskers are too brittle. We used a cross section through both MLCC termination solder and some whiskers ends to be contacted with Silver epoxy ink.

      Fig8: cross section in the vertical plan contacting the MLCC solder and the whiskers ends. Both were contacted with silver epoxy. The realization of the micro-section as much as the precise deposit of the silver lacquer are difficult to achieve.
      Fig9: Verification of the contact, and measure 2 probes. The whiskers are not conductive (or not contacted). A verification was done by contacting both ends of a single whiskers.
      Fig10: Verification of the whiskers resistance done by contacting both ends of a single whiskers: not conductive

      Tin tubes growth hypothesis

      While lowering the reflow temperature profile, more hollow whiskers were possible to be generated. This suggests that the SnO hollow whiskers growth mechanism is promoted by some still active flux residues not fully desactivated by the reflow process. Among these residues the weak organic acids (WOA) and halogen/bromine are suspected to contribute to the growth mechanism of SnO whisker.

      Tin hydroxide chloride [Sn3O2(OH)2-xClx] was reported to be intermediate corrosion products on reaction from Sn to SnO/SnO2 (depending on pH and presence of chlorine halogen) [7]. A similar Tin hydroxide bromide could have been the intermediate corrosion product to give rise to the tin oxide hollow whisker encountered:

      Fig11: corrosion of Tin layer with intermediate Tin hydroxide halogen [7]

      This localized corrosion process in presence of halogen ion (bromine) could have been at the origin of the tube shape observed. The transformation of Tin nanowires to amorphous oxide nanotubes has been described by HoSun Shin [8] based on a localized corrosion process in an aqueous solution involving hydrochloric acids (from halogen chlorine ion). The nano-tubes were formed by the dissolution of the tin atoms in the core of the “nanowire” while the tin oxide shell was remaining.

      Conclusion

      Hollow Tin Wiskers are transparent, very brittle and not conductive.

      We demonstrated no risk of leakage or short circuit. At visual inspection they can be considered as cosmetic.

      Growth mechanism is supected to come from a localized corrosion process by a Bromine acidic solution from the Solder flux residues and the moisture from the humid atmosphere of the damp heat test.

      References

      1) JEDEC STANDARD JESD22-A121A “Test Method for Measuring Whisker Growth on Tin and Tin Alloy Surface Finishes”, July 2008.
      2) JEDEC STANDARD JESD201A “Environmental Acceptance Requirements for Tin Whisker Susceptibility of Tin and Tin Alloy Surface Finishes”, Sept. 2008.
      3) Jay A. Brusse, Gary J. Ewell, and Jocelyn P. Siplon, “Tin Whiskers: Attributes and Mitigation”, CARTS 2002: 22nd Capacitor and Resistor Technology Symposium, 25-29 March 2002
      4) H. Kehrer and H. Kadereit, “Tracer Experiments on the Growth of Tin Whiskers,” Applied Physics Letters, 16, no. 11, pp. 411-412, June 1, 1970.
      5) Jing Cheng, Paul T. Vianco, and James C.M. Li, “Hollow tin/chromium whiskers”, Applied Physics Letters, 96, 184102, 2010.
      6) David Hillman, “False tin-whiskers – beware of masquerading tin-copper intermetallics”, ITRI, 2012
      7) Pierre Eckold, “Corrosion of Tin and its Influence on Whisker Growth”, 7th IPC–CALCE International ymposium on Tin Whiskers, November 12-13, 2013.
      8) Ho SunShin, Seong GiJeon, JinYu, Jae YongSong, “Transformation of Sn nanowires to oxide nanotubes by a localized corrosion process”, Materials Letters Volume 82, 1 September 2012.

      Acknowledgements

      Special Thanks to José Gomes from ILED. Investigation Laboratory for Electronic Devices Site Montesquieu 8 Allée Isaac Newton 33650 Martillac-France


      more 2nd PCNS symposium technical papers can be viewed and downloaded in pdf from EPCI Academy e-Proceedings:

      Previous Post

      Conductive Hybrid Threads and Their Applications

      Next Post

      Reliable supply of tantalum, now and going forward

      Related Posts

      ESA SPCD

      New Generation of Wafer-Scale, Hermetically Sealed Chip Fuse for Space Applications

      14
      ESA SPCD

      Miniature RF Switch MEMR for Compact Redundancy Ring

      11
      ESA SPCD

      Low Profile Solderless Flat Interconnect for Space Applications

      38

      Discussion about this post

      Categories

      • ABC of CLR
        • ABC of Capacitors
        • ABC of Inductors
        • ABC of Resistors
        • Mounting Guidelines
      • e-Symposium
        • ESA SPCD
        • PCNS
      • EPCI news
      • news collection

      Popular Posts

      • Transformer: Parasitic parameters and equivalent circuit

        1212 shares
        Share 485 Tweet 303
      • Transformer Calculation and Applications

        662 shares
        Share 265 Tweet 166
      • Simulation with LTspice

        446 shares
        Share 178 Tweet 112
      • Introduction to Ceramic Capacitors

        443 shares
        Share 177 Tweet 111
      • Insulation Resistance, DCL Leakage Current and Voltage Breakdown

        412 shares
        Share 165 Tweet 103

      EPCI Membership

      join passive components community

      © 2023 European Passive Components Institute

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • ABC of CLR
        • ABC of Capacitors
        • ABC of Inductors
        • ABC of Resistors
        • Mounting Guidelines
      • e-Symposium
      • EPCI Membership
      • About

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In
      This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.